The epic sci­ence fic­tion showdown

Space bat­tles involv­ing thou­sands of star­ships with real­is­tic tac­tics…
Fac­tional pol­i­tick­ing with enough chain strat­a­gems and Just-as-Planned to keep your head spin­ning…
Some of the most awe­some and intel­lec­tu­ally witty lead­ers ever…
Deep sto­ry­line that ref­er­ences major events from thou­sands of years of human history…

There are many rea­sons to watch Leg­end of the Galac­tic Heroes, which is one of the few series that I claim to be one of the best anime series ever pro­duced, regard­less of sub­jec­tive inter­ests. Mat­ter of fact I believe its enjoy­ment rises with your intel­lec­tual knowl­edge and, by the time you’re done, you’d feel that even the intim­i­dat­ing num­ber of 110 episodes weren’t enough.

But Galac­tic Heroes also had its flaws and short­com­ings, many of which inher­ited from its scifi Space Opera sub-genre. Per­son­ally, Galac­tic Heroes could have improved greatly if it took a few more ele­ments from its sib­ling sub­genre: Mil­i­tary Scifi, which is best rep­re­sented in the ani­mev­erse by Ban­ner of the Stars, arguably also the clos­est thing to Galac­tic Heroes inso­far as epic scifi anime goes. If you enjoyed one, you’ll love the other. Read the rest of this entry »

As a hob­by­ist world­forger, Lelangiric’s post and Eternal’s con­tin­u­a­tion on how the mechanics/setting of anime tends to fall short of expec­ta­tions actu­ally ticks me off a lit­tle bit. Not quite because of their view­points, but because mod­ern Japan­ese ani­ma­tion, and much of recent scifi/fantasy in gen­eral, are a rather poor gauge on mea­sur­ing the lit­er­ary val­ues of set­ting cre­ativ­ity. But then, that’s also par­tially our fault as the viewers…

Expo­si­tion start: acti­vate lec­ture mode! (and who remem­bers this old yet remark­able anime?)

By and most in today’s series, we don’t have ‘set­ting’. More pre­cisely, we have a very much watered down ver­sion of ‘set­ting’ which is far bet­ter enti­tled ‘premise’. The dif­fer­ence between these two? A set­ting attempts to round out the details behind all the pri­mary con­cepts and mechan­ics it intro­duce. It goes beyond just those two ini­tial lines of con­cep­tual expla­na­tions and seeks to reflect the cast’s under­stand­ing of their World to the audi­ence, with­out inhi­bi­tions or con­ve­nient cutouts. On the other hand, a premise is a set of con­cepts and mechan­ics sim­ply handed to the audi­ence with min­i­mum scrutiny, and the viewer is expected to accept it in order to make the story work. ‘Premises’ can be upgraded to ‘set­ting’ through sto­ry­telling, but with­out intri­cate detail­ing and/or in-depth analy­sis, it will always remain what is it: merely a premise, a set of ideas and foun­da­tions, not a World.

Read the rest of this entry »