As Giz­modo was kind enough to remind us all on how soci­ety view Otakus, I find myself once again tem­porar­ily agree­ing with the Otaku Elim­i­na­tion Game (the hor­ror of it!) on all the Dan­ny­Choo wannabe blogs.

Otaku
These folks are totally obsessed with Japan and its anime cul­ture, col­lect­ing all sorts of fig­urines of either huge-breasted fan­tasy girls or shy-looking school­girls and hav­ing book­shelves full of manga books and anime DVDs. They replace nor­mal social inter­ac­tions with hours spent fan­ta­siz­ing about a world that doesn’t actu­ally exist. Sad would be the word for it.

Yeah, it’s easy to claim they don’t under­stand, but sadly this seems to be what we’re com­ing off to the rest of soci­ety as.

So what if it’s book­shelves full of manga and anime DVDs, there’s plenty of peo­ple how there with shelves full of movie DVDs and music CDs, not because they’re nec­es­sar­ily a movie/music geek but because they like it. This can be left sim­ply as a case of anime fan­dom not quite accepted by West­ern soci­ety yet, and I’ll be inter­ested to see what they say another decade down the line with the cur­rent trends of growth. How­ever, other mer­chan­dise such as fig­ures, and espe­cially things like daki­makuras, will always have a stigma to them.

Don’t get me wrong. I don’t mind the col­lec­tion of fig­ures, plushies, gun­pla, wallscrolls, posters, etc. I have a few of each of those things so I’d be an exces­sive hyp­ocrite oth­er­wise (although I will always say NO! to daki­makuras). Fur­ther­more, when you look at it from another per­spec­tive, it’s no dif­fer­ent from tap­ing up the poster of your favorite singer, or col­lect­ing stuffed ani­mals, or reg­u­lar mod­el­ling (still geeky, mind).

But it’s those who rant end­lessly about how they spent all of their life earn­ings on anime goods and then shouts out to the inter­net non­stop about how cool it is that annoys me. I know you’re proud of your col­lec­tion, but I don’t need to see 42 posts per month on it and be forced to assume that out­side anime mer­chan­dis­ing and mer­chan­dise blog­ging you have noth­ing else to live for. I don’t even know what to say about those who carry daki­makuras in pub­lic just to draw atten­tion, or any­one who made news head­lines by mar­ry­ing girls from Love Plus. I know I’m prob­a­bly just shov­el­ing blame off onto oth­ers here and will feel bad about this post the moment I press pub­lish, but seri­ously the next time you pub­licly do some­thing out­ra­geous, think about how it will hurt the way soci­ety views us and all our com­rades (I prob­a­bly need to reflect on some actions as well). After all, do you think the rest of the com­mu­nity really appre­ci­ates being asso­ci­ated by the gen­eral pub­lic with that guy who walks around brag­ging about his 2D waifu?

See­ing as ‘Otaku’ are fas­ci­nated about every­thing else Japan, they should also learn from Japan­ese cul­ture on keep­ing the more obses­sive parts of your life private:

Japan­ese soci­ety will tol­er­ate a wide range of per­sonal habits, idio­syn­crasies, behav­iors, and hob­bies so long as they remain behind closed doors. As anime direc­tor Mamoru Hosoda has noted, vir­tu­ally every­one online in Japan uses an anony­mous nick­name. The pub­lic and the pri­vate in Japan are expected to be strictly sep­a­rated. — Ani­me­Na­tion

I can’t say any­thing about escapism, although this is a prob­lem that applies to far more than just anime. But if you’re one of those peo­ple who dis­re­gards your real-life friends for anime or buries your­self in manga to for­get about how your life is stu­pid and point­less: you’re just as bad as World of War­craft addicts and needs help. Using it to tem­porar­ily dis­tract your­self from some­thing bad is fine though, lit­er­ally every­one is guilty of this one point or another.

*awaits ston­ing*

10 Responses to “Perception of Otaku and Merchandise Blogging”
  1. In the end, I think it all comes down to hav­ing a sober judge­ment of one’s self. That Giz­modo piece is just point­ing out the degree of social awk­ward­ness typ­i­cally asso­ci­ated with the hobby. As you alluded to, if we wanted to increase the “accept­abil­ity” of this hobby, we’d sim­ply have to be more socially aware and respectable. We could do that with­out nec­es­sar­ily chang­ing hob­bies — it just takes time and effort to change society’s view (like, notice how gamers have moved up on the charts over the past 5–10 years).

    But the rea­son this won’t hap­pen is actu­ally related to the rea­sons why geek cul­ture turns against some­one like a Danny Choo (or why the hard­core gamers turned against Spike’s Video Game Awards in the U.S.). There’s an insa­tiable desire to be “counter-culture”, and to not give in to society’s desire for con­for­mity. As some­one like Danny con­tin­ues to gain more main­stream accep­tance for “bishoujo-fandom” and him­self, geeks will turn against him for not being a “true geek” (or a “Real Otaku”) and polluting/diluting the hobby. Rather than see­ing him as a model and suc­cess story, they see him as a trai­tor and a wannabe (and any­one that tries to fol­low in his foot­steps will be a Fool’s Dis­ci­ple). And that fur­ther fuels the death spi­ral of social unac­cept­abil­ity and deeper entrench­ment that keeps the hobby near the bot­tom of the pack. There are entire com­mu­ni­ties on the Inter­net that seem to have as their mis­sion to embrace and extend the social unac­cept­abil­ity of this hobby (often even mak­ing things up to make things seem worse than they really are), sim­ply out of some sort of bizarre sense of fun and rebel­lion. And down­trod­den though they may be, no com­mu­nity is faster to turn on their own. I don’t think cer­tain peo­ple want things to change.

    So, this may be a self-serving posi­tion, but I don’t think col­lect­ing mer­chan­dise or even talk­ing about it is the big prob­lem here, stigma or not. It’s quite pos­si­ble to over­come that stigma by just being a “nor­mal, mature human being”. Peo­ple may think you’re weird, but at least you can still be respectable. For me per­son­ally, the main rea­son I talk about the mer­chan­dise I col­lect is sim­ply to share with oth­ers who might be inter­ested, so they can live vic­ar­i­ously through my fool­ish­ness. And, in per­haps my own lit­tle bit of rebel­lion, if that makes you feel awk­ward or threat­ened about shar­ing some aspects of this hobby, then I would have to push *some* of that back onto you as well. After all, I don’t think this hobby is nec­es­sar­ily some­thing to be ashamed of, even if the behav­iour of cer­tain peo­ple who share this hobby some­times causes us to feel ashamed.
    relentlessflame´s last blog ..This is not a ret­ro­spec­tive. (It is a bit NSFW, though. Don’t act so sur­prised…) My ComLuv Profile

  2. sakura says:

    Well at least we’re above the ‘Fur­ries’ right? ;)

    Hubby and I just buy stuff because we think it looks cool, or we really were a fan of the show. I get my model kits because I really do enjoy putting them together. The first kit I ever put together was a model of the USS Enter­prise NCC-1701-A from Star Trek, so its not a hobby that is lim­ited to anime itself.

    I put pic­tures of my kits up because I know that there are few other blog­gers other than myself that will find them inter­est­ing since they are also Macross fans.

    As that arti­cle points out if you are really obses­sive over it, then you can really be con­sid­ered a geek of any­thing. I guess as you say that’s the point. Get your enjoy­ment out of it, but don’t let it become your life.

    I’ll take a day out with hubby over build­ing a model kit or watch­ing a show any time!
    sakura´s last blog ..I didn’t expect that My ComLuv Profile

  3. Aorii says:

    @relentlessflame
    Well like I men­tioned, I’m not against mer­chan­dise for the sake of it. That entire counter-culture thing is sort of BS in my opin­ion. I’ve rarely cared much about Dan­ny­Choo, as he can be an otaku the way he likes for all I care. But it’s the fact that fig­ures like him stands out to ‘rep­re­sent’ us in soci­ety and thus caus­ing every­one to believe that otaku, or any­one heav­ily con­sum­ing Japan­ese mod­ern visual cul­ture, is sim­i­lar to Dan­ny­Choo that’s annoy­ing me. Yeah, it’s prob­a­bly not his fault and I’m just seek­ing some­thing to lash out against (imma­ture huh?), but I think the fact so many blog­gers jump on the Dan­ny­Choo band­wagon makes other think: oh, he’s not just an extreme case, the rest of them really are that way. Those news arti­cles about Love Plus doesn’t help either.

    @sakura
    Three step process of nor­mal -> geek -> obses­sion I guess. We’re all geeks of some­thing around here. It sim­ply seems to be a mat­ter of not cross­ing that line.

  4. […] is an inter­est­ing com­ment by relent­less­flame over at Major Arcana about how crit­i­ciz­ing out­go­ing fans like Danny Choo is tan­ta­mount to refus­ing progress towards […]

  5. lelangir says:

    Well, rock&roll was the devil’s music, but now you don’t see any­one complaining…

  6. @Aorii
    I com­mented on mt-i’s blog and I think it largely addresses the issue you’re point­ing out. Although he’s out­go­ing and a bit in-your-face, I guess I hadn’t really con­sid­ered Danny Choo to be an exam­ple of an “extreme case”. OEG actu­ally keeps say­ing that he, and his “fol­low­ers”, are not “Otaku enough”. What you’re sort of allud­ing to here is that you find his unabashed pro­mo­tion of the more ques­tion­able aspects of this hobby to be embar­rass­ing, and you wish he (and his “kind”) would just keep things to them­selves a bit more in order to not make “the rest of us” look bad. But yeah… on this point I sort of think that if some peo­ple didn’t stand out in front and take the “hits”, we’d have no mid­dle ground to cling to either. Any­way… it’s a good dis­cus­sion to be hav­ing, I think.
    relentlessflame´s last blog ..Today from around the anime blo­gos­phere… My ComLuv Profile

  7. Honya says:

    relent­less­flame pretty much nailed it. Regard­less of our own par­tic­u­lar tastes and how socially awk­ward it may be a large part of it comes down to how we project our­selves to soci­ety. As long as we act maturely about it I don’t see much prob­lem in this. In the end us blog­gers are just doing what we like and shar­ing what we love for oth­ers to enjoy. Sure we may not like what cer­tain indi­vid­u­als do or how they rep­re­sent us but attack­ing them can also makes us look just as bad as them. I’d rather just ignore them and con­tinue to do what I enjoy whether it be show­ing off mer­chan­dise or trans­lat­ing or whatnot.

  8. Netto says:

    Every­one has their own fair share of fandom-ism or some­thing like that, so it’s nat­ural for them to express in ways that they like. Some­times, of course, things tends to get out of hand, thus you’ll see peo­ple walk­ing around the streets with those daki­makura and even that mar­riage with Love Plus like you’ve mentioned!

    After all, blog­ging is a plat­form for many to share their views about things, and anime prod­ucts such as fig­urines and (ugh) daki­makura are often one of the eas­i­est way for any­one to blog about, sim­ply because they just requires pic­tures and lit­tle words. It isn’t too bad, unless the whole post is about them hug­ging those daki­makuras or filled with “AHHH I LOVE THIS!!” etc etc. In fact, those posts about fig­urines are most of the time infor­ma­tive, as it allows the read­ers to have a clearer view on the fig­urine before decid­ing on such a heavy invest­ment! I’m not sure about daki­makura, since I’ve yet to see one post about it out­side Danny’s site.

    At the end of the day, humans are still social beings. The desire to share and (maybe) brag and stuffs like that is always in every sin­gle per­son, so it would be rather dif­fi­cult to actu­ally “end” all of these. There’s still the issue of “degrad­ing of the com­mu­nity by otaku” as many would put it, but what can you truly do asides from talk­ing about it? Attack them so that they will dis­ap­pear from the face of the inter­net? That would only fuel revenge.

    Best solu­tion? Just leave them be, like they are affect­ing any­thing you’re doing in your daily life! Sooner or later, they will adapt bet­ter ways, or even stop entirely!
    Netto´s last blog ..“Work­ing!!” Slice-Of-Life Anime Trailer Released! My ComLuv Profile

  9. Aorii says:

    Of course, there’s also the mat­ter of what level of pub­lic dis­play in fan­dom still con­sti­tutes under the “mature” rat­ing. I do have to agree with Netto that a lot of those fig­ure posts actu­ally are infor­ma­tive. Heck, I once bought a fig­ure I wouldn’t have oth­er­wise due to a post review­ing it. That’s legit­i­mate prod­uct review­ing. Think­ing back, it’s the peo­ple who love to take snap­shots of an absurdly messy room with shelves full of fig­ur­ings while the rest of the floor is cov­ered by barbage and post it with tremen­dous “otaku pride” that annoys me. Either way though, you guys are right that attack­ing such wouldn’t do any­thing, I’ll just dis­pose of that in the men­tal garbage bin and hope for a social per­cep­tion switch (like that of video games) a decade or so from now…

  10. Crystal says:

    Well, the most we can do is just let them be them­selves. Some peo­ple can spend a lot on their hob­bies, and some don’t. Peo­ple find dif­fer­ent val­ues in things. I myself don’t like daki­makuras but I do like some fig­urines, but not a whole room full. The peo­ple on the news for crazy things prob­a­bly don’t care how they appear in pub­lic, they just wanna do what they wanna do. [You could also say one of the awk­ward things about anime too is most of the pop­u­la­tion is male dom­i­nated watch­ing cute shows. But noth­ing stops them and they enjoy it any­ways.] Being happy themselves.

    Of course, there are peo­ple who don’t have anime as a hobby/obsession but have other hobbies/obessions as well. Peo­ple that play video games a lot, talk and watch about sports a lot, addicted to drinking/gambling/shopping, that sort of thing. It’s just that anime and manga is still a recent thing, but in the west it’s not that famil­iar. But slowly…the manga selec­tion at my book­store grows each year.

    Anime/manga cul­ture is becom­ing more pop­u­lar all over the world. There’s no doubt it’ll keep increase in pop­u­lar­ity and peo­ple get­ting inter­est­ing in it. Some­times humans don’t really like change at first. Maybe one day it’ll be com­mon to see anime being open­ing talked about in pub­lic, rather than peo­ple hid­ing it in their rooms. Every­one has a pref­er­ence on what they want to do with their hobby, whether it’s col­lect­ing, cos­play­ing, blog­ging, or just marathon­ing your favorite dvds. You should enjoy what makes you happy rather than focus­ing on what other peo­ple do.
    Crystal´s last blog ..Crap weekend-Update My ComLuv Profile

  11.  
Leave a Reply

CommentLuv Enabled