Sword Art Online Light-Novel Review: Addictive Unoriginality
Posted by Aorii in Light Novels, tags: Light Novel, Reki Kawahara, Review, Sword Art Online, Virtual RealityYes, it’s done! We finished our work on it! The legendary web novel that accrued over 6.5 million views on a personal site has now been brought to English!
From merely the description, Sword Art Online is a novel that’s easy to pass and ignore. Its premise is ridiculous yet hardly original. Its characters are very cliche. Its plot and character development are relatively simple and utilize some very common tropes. Its art and character designs remind one of Ragnarok Online. Everything about it screams generic scifi/fantasy written for gamers by a gamer. Yet despite all that, Reki Kawahara’s work is a piece of art that leaves any reader with the slighest MMO experience doubtless of SAO’s popularity and why he is the grand prize winner of the 2008 Dengeki Novel Prize. The truth is a simple one, easily discernible once you flip past the first few pages:
His storytelling style is simply intoxicating
Jason of blog好き once compared the premise of SAO to a merge of Dot Hack and Tower of Druaga. Yes, it’s about 10,000 hardcore gamers who were trapped inside a virtual reality MMORPG and cannot exit until they climb to the top of an 100 story tower and defeat its final boss. Unlike the gamer’s dream, death within this Matrix also meant death in real life — no saves, no respawns. It’s quite the ridiculous premise: a deadly experiment prepared by the game’s mad scientist creator that trapped 10,000 unwillingly souls as its subjects.
We follow the adventures of yet another generic main character, a lone wolf with a tragic past, who meets up with the number one bishoujo gamer of within SAO — and what, she’s in love with the main but is being slightly tsundere about it? All for a reason that seemed to have dropped out of some cheap visual novel? Is this the next self-insertable moe story or something? Well, that might be part of SAO’s appeal—
But I’m reminded yet again that there is a value to stereotypes and tropes — their unoriginality makes them easy to understand, easy to sympathize with, easy to get in character.
This is where Kawahara-sensei’s writing comes in. Without any unnecessary verbosity, his precisely detailed descriptions paints every frame of the story vividly within the reader’s mind. We’re quickly tossed into a straightforward main story with minimum expositionary delay. With simple concepts, events, and characters, it’s easy to fall in line with the main leads, think his thoughts and feel his emotions. Combine this with Kawahara’s attention to detail and the story’s first-person perspective which describes to us exactly what the main character sees, hears, feels, and does, we quickly get in sync with him. As a result, everything that happens gains a sense of personal attachment, be it his guilt as a sole survivor, his desire for alone time with his beloved, or his confusion regarding the real-world versus game-world issues. Finally, add some icing on the cake through Kawahara’s excellent use of foreshadowing, a few well-placed cliffhangers, and several brilliantly told melodrama scenes, and we have one addicting and highly enjoyable novel.
[ 茨乃 ]
Matter of fact, Kawahara’s writing is the reason I ended up working on the project — I wanted to keep as few of those vivid descriptions from being lost in translation as possible.
As I mentioned, the first volume has finished translation and editing at Baka-Tsuki, which covers all of the main story within the first SAO game (PDF)(Backup) . The second volume, which we’re moving directly into, will feature four short stories that happens before the first volume to further shape the SAO world, its mechanics, its inhabitants, and our lead characters; the main story will then continue in volume 3 in another game.
In the long run though, SAO might become another game-like novel series (like ZnT), except where Kirito picks up party members while hopping between different MMOs.





Entries (RSS)
Ooh, this looks interesting.
.-= mefloraine´s last blog ..Kaichou wa Maid-sama, anyone? =-.
it sounds interesting~
.-= warriorhope´s last blog ..Love Celeb Volume 1 =-.
@mefloraine @warriorhope :
It is, and hope you give it a shot o/
My friend has some of this novel =)
he told me it is good, now you tell me its in english.
Ill check it out.
sounds very interesting.
.-= Fabrice´s last blog ..On Order: Kotobukiya Hitagi Senjogahara =-.
Well English fan trans anyhow. An actually localized version might take a few years at least xD
Hope you like it o/
Curse my bad eyesight. Maybe it’ll come out over here someday.
.-= Janette´s last blog ..Heartcatch Precure 10: Do We Have to Go Back To The Main Story? =-.
I’ve been interested in this since I saw Jason’s post, but this pretty much decides it for me. From your description, SAO sounds like exactly the kind of generic story that I’d actually enjoy.
.-= ETERNAL´s last blog ..Crying Your True Tears =-.
@Janette: One can always hope /o/
@ETERNAL: Alright looks like it finally tipped the scale! New convert \o/
Made a PDF of Volume 1 (Aincrad) from S.A.O.
http://www.mediafire.com/?nx3zgkyyt0i
It is quite a shame sentences or certain words aren’t italicized,
nonetheless thank you for Sword Art Online!
Alright thanks a bunch o/
I’ll post this to the main site too
It’s a rather rigged up draft.. (a blank page, some awkward spacings, etc.) Besides chapter 16.5 has been omitted aswell.
Here’s the .docx file:
http://www.mediafire.com/?z1xezz1dngj
Awesome job, looking extremely forward to Volume 2.
Nice stuff. Just finished reading this after receiving a recc from my friend. Had no idea you were part of the team which translated this. XD only figured out after i tried googling for images.
Sigh… I feel powerless. Maybe that’ll change in awhile once i have time to learn Japanese.
But until then, I’ll be relying on you guys for my daily dose of entertainment XD
Lol I wish we could still send out chapters almost daily like we used to; team now isn’t what it used to be =\
But glad you enjoyed it~
Oh my word? You’re part of the translation project for this? I started this directly after HakoMari and was instantly hooked! Thanks for making this available to us and I do hope you keep translating ^^”
(I’ve been waiting for months xD)
Yeah we’ve been slacking xD and the new translators don’t have the same pace as Sharramon once did x3
But it’ll get there— bit slowly but surely
I just finished the first volume recently and I really enjoyed it. I appreciate your translations but I was wondering that since the next couple of volumes are side stories will they ever pick up where volume 1 left off?
Vol 2. is full of side-stories. Vol 3 picks up where it left off with delving into another game… I just haven’t gotten updates from my 2 translators for a while >.<
Well, first of all I want to thank you. It’s thanks to you translators that I can enjoy reading a masterpiece like Sword Art Online. I’m not used to doing this but I needed to show how much I appreciate your work and encourage you and the rest of the translators to keep up with the good work.
I’m soooo looking forward to more updates… SAO is just too great.
Well, thanks again!
Technically I think I’m in a retired status until further notice as a faster group picked it up, so drop by Baka-Tsuki forums to thank them x)
Nevertheless I’m glad it got rolling~
Guess I’ll do so too :P
Anyway, that you are now in a retired status doesn’t erase the work you’ve done until now, so thanks for the third time xD
Oh, just found your Remember 11 review. I read Ever 17 some time ago and I just remembered I wanted to read that one too. Just felt like telling you.
Well, congratulations for having such a nice blog ^^
Anybody read this one? It has a similar premise to Sword Art online.
Moonlight Sculptor
Synopsis: The master of flattery who will pour praises upon NPCs if it will get him one more copper coin! The avatar of hard work who is willing to hit a dummy without rest for 1 month in order to gain stats! For Wid everything and anything he does in the virutal reality of Royal Road is related to his one goal.
Make money, become number one and use the fame and power to make even more money. Enough to say goodbye to poverty forever!
What he doesn’t know however is that fate has another thing in mind for him…
- One of, if not the most popular game novel series in Korea, Moonlight Sculptor follows the development of the main Character (Wid) through his trials and tribulations. Through the story so far he has picked up new friends, admirers, and devoted enemies aplenty from his time as the terror of the Continent of Magic (A game he played before starting RR). A character who overcomes impossible odds through sheer hard work without relying on any bugs or balance breaking items! Read this and you won’t be disappointed!
the first volume is already translated to English from Korean.
Oh cool, I’ll check it out; do love these kind of series. Thanks for the recommend~! ^o^
Yeah I have to second this story. The plot is great and it’s really really interesting. The only thing that bothers me is that the second volume isn’t translated and can’t find the raws for the story anywhere.
I believe the new translation group is still working on that one…
I quote every word you used.
I also think the first arc should have ended without the last chapter, which I found really disappointing in its anticlimax and inconsistency.
He could choose another main character and follow similar stories in others worlds for next volumes.
Yet he decided to continue telling a story of characters that had already told all they had to tell.
Lack of plot planning and courage to BE a writer, and not just selling books imho. Really a pity.
Mmmh, I have mixed feelings on that one. Keep going with a character after its developed isn’t necessarily a bad thing. A character that’s set up allows more focus on story and, to my great pleasure in SAO, setting (I love the MMO seed).
Also to be fair, the light novel industry (and manga) doesn’t exactly encourage long-term planning from the beginning, not unless you’re famous already (which Reki wasn’t) and knows what you wrote is going to be published for long time to come.
i really liked the story of this anime.. can anyone suggest other animes that has the same story concept like this one? of course aside from hunter x hunter which i already saw the greed island chapter which was awesome and just like sword art online.. please do tell me guys if you know other animes that are like this..
Honestly, the English version is pretty bad. The plotline doesn’t connect, and the translation isn’t great. It sounds like more of a mechanical structure rather than a piece of work. I found myself having a hard time following the story and remaining interested.
Anime was much better. ;p