Yes, it’s done! We fin­ished our work on it! The leg­endary web novel that accrued over 6.5 mil­lion views on a per­sonal site has now been brought to English!

From merely the descrip­tion, Sword Art Online is a novel that’s easy to pass and ignore. Its premise is ridicu­lous yet hardly orig­i­nal. Its char­ac­ters are very cliche. Its plot and char­ac­ter devel­op­ment are rel­a­tively sim­ple and uti­lize some very com­mon tropes. Its art and char­ac­ter designs remind one of Rag­narok Online. Every­thing about it screams generic scifi/fantasy writ­ten for gamers by a gamer. Yet despite all that, Reki Kawahara’s work is a piece of art that leaves any reader with the sligh­est MMO expe­ri­ence doubt­less of SAO’s pop­u­lar­ity and why he is the grand prize win­ner of the 2008 Dengeki Novel Prize. The truth is a sim­ple one, eas­ily dis­cernible once you flip past the first few pages:

His sto­ry­telling style is sim­ply intoxicating

Jason of blog好き once com­pared the premise of SAO to a merge of Dot Hack and Tower of Dru­aga. Yes, it’s about 10,000 hard­core gamers who were trapped inside a vir­tual real­ity MMORPG and can­not exit until they climb to the top of an 100 story tower and defeat its final boss. Unlike the gamer’s dream, death within this Matrix also meant death in real life — no saves, no respawns. It’s quite the ridicu­lous premise: a deadly exper­i­ment pre­pared by the game’s mad sci­en­tist cre­ator that trapped 10,000 unwill­ingly souls as its subjects.

We fol­low the adven­tures of yet another generic main char­ac­ter, a lone wolf with a tragic past, who meets up with the num­ber one bishoujo gamer of within SAO — and what, she’s in love with the main but is being slightly tsun­dere about it? All for a rea­son that seemed to have dropped out of some cheap visual novel? Is this the next self-insertable moe story or some­thing? Well, that might be part of SAO’s appeal—

But I’m reminded yet again that there is a value to stereo­types and tropes — their uno­rig­i­nal­ity makes them easy to under­stand, easy to sym­pa­thize with, easy to get in character.

This is where Kawahara-sensei’s writ­ing comes in. With­out any unnec­es­sary ver­bosity, his pre­cisely detailed descrip­tions paints every frame of the story vividly within the reader’s mind. We’re quickly tossed into a straight­for­ward main story with min­i­mum expo­si­tionary delay. With sim­ple con­cepts, events, and char­ac­ters, it’s easy to fall in line with the main leads, think his thoughts and feel his emo­tions. Com­bine this with Kawahara’s atten­tion to detail and the story’s first-person per­spec­tive which describes to us exactly what the main char­ac­ter sees, hears, feels, and does, we quickly get in sync with him. As a result, every­thing that hap­pens gains a sense of per­sonal attach­ment, be it his guilt as a sole sur­vivor, his desire for alone time with his beloved, or his con­fu­sion regard­ing the real-world ver­sus game-world issues. Finally, add some icing on the cake through Kawahara’s excel­lent use of fore­shad­ow­ing, a few well-placed cliffhang­ers, and sev­eral bril­liantly told melo­drama scenes, and we have one addict­ing and highly enjoy­able novel.

[ 茨乃 ]

Mat­ter of fact, Kawahara’s writ­ing is the rea­son I ended up work­ing on the project — I wanted to keep as few of those vivid descrip­tions from being lost in trans­la­tion as possible.

As I men­tioned, the first vol­ume has fin­ished trans­la­tion and edit­ing at Baka-Tsuki, which cov­ers all of the main story within the first SAO game (PDF)(Backup) . The sec­ond vol­ume, which we’re mov­ing directly into, will fea­ture four short sto­ries that hap­pens before the first vol­ume to fur­ther shape the SAO world, its mechan­ics, its inhab­i­tants, and our lead char­ac­ters; the main story will then con­tinue in vol­ume 3 in another game.

In the long run though, SAO might become another game-like novel series (like ZnT), except where Kir­ito picks up party mem­bers while hop­ping between dif­fer­ent MMOs.

Pos­si­bly Related Posts

29 Responses to “Sword Art Online Light-Novel Review: Addictive Unoriginality”
  1. mefloraine says:

    Ooh, this looks inter­est­ing.
    .-= mefloraine´s last blog ..Kai­chou wa Maid-sama, any­one? =-.

  2. warriorhope says:

    it sounds inter­est­ing~
    .-= warriorhope´s last blog ..Love Celeb Vol­ume 1 =-.

  3. Aorii says:

    @mefloraine @warriorhope :
    It is, and hope you give it a shot o/

  4. Fabrice says:

    My friend has some of this novel =)
    he told me it is good, now you tell me its in eng­lish.
    Ill check it out.

    sounds very inter­est­ing.
    .-= Fabrice´s last blog ..On Order: Koto­bukiya Hitagi Sen­jo­ga­hara =-.

    • Aorii says:

      Well Eng­lish fan trans any­how. An actu­ally local­ized ver­sion might take a few years at least xD
      Hope you like it o/

  5. Janette says:

    Curse my bad eye­sight. Maybe it’ll come out over here some­day.
    .-= Janette´s last blog ..Heart­catch Pre­cure 10: Do We Have to Go Back To The Main Story? =-.

  6. ETERNAL says:

    I’ve been inter­ested in this since I saw Jason’s post, but this pretty much decides it for me. From your descrip­tion, SAO sounds like exactly the kind of generic story that I’d actu­ally enjoy.
    .-= ETERNAL´s last blog ..Cry­ing Your True Tears =-.

  7. Aorii says:

    @Janette: One can always hope /o/

    @ETERNAL: Alright looks like it finally tipped the scale! New con­vert \o/

  8. Aergia says:

    Made a PDF of Vol­ume 1 (Ain­crad) from S.A.O.
    http://www.mediafire.com/?nx3zgkyyt0i

    It is quite a shame sen­tences or cer­tain words aren’t ital­i­cized,
    nonethe­less thank you for Sword Art Online!

  9. Alex says:

    Awe­some job, look­ing extremely for­ward to Vol­ume 2.

  10. LX says:

    Nice stuff. Just fin­ished read­ing this after receiv­ing a recc from my friend. Had no idea you were part of the team which trans­lated this. XD only fig­ured out after i tried googling for images.

    Sigh… I feel pow­er­less. Maybe that’ll change in awhile once i have time to learn Japanese.

    But until then, I’ll be rely­ing on you guys for my daily dose of enter­tain­ment XD

    • Aorii says:

      Lol I wish we could still send out chap­ters almost daily like we used to; team now isn’t what it used to be =\
      But glad you enjoyed it~

  11. Ayasuna says:

    Oh my word? You’re part of the trans­la­tion project for this? I started this directly after Hako­Mari and was instantly hooked! Thanks for mak­ing this avail­able to us and I do hope you keep translating ^^”

    (I’ve been wait­ing for months xD)

    • Aorii says:

      Yeah we’ve been slack­ing xD and the new trans­la­tors don’t have the same pace as Shar­ra­mon once did x3
      But it’ll get there— bit slowly but surely

  12. KiD CoRy says:

    I just fin­ished the first vol­ume recently and I really enjoyed it. I appre­ci­ate your trans­la­tions but I was won­der­ing that since the next cou­ple of vol­umes are side sto­ries will they ever pick up where vol­ume 1 left off?

    • Aorii says:

      Vol 2. is full of side-stories. Vol 3 picks up where it left off with delv­ing into another game… I just haven’t got­ten updates from my 2 trans­la­tors for a while >.<

  13. Darkhanum says:

    Well, first of all I want to thank you. It’s thanks to you trans­la­tors that I can enjoy read­ing a mas­ter­piece like Sword Art Online. I’m not used to doing this but I needed to show how much I appre­ci­ate your work and encour­age you and the rest of the trans­la­tors to keep up with the good work.

    I’m soooo look­ing for­ward to more updates… SAO is just too great.

    Well, thanks again!

    • Aorii says:

      Tech­ni­cally I think I’m in a retired sta­tus until fur­ther notice as a faster group picked it up, so drop by Baka-Tsuki forums to thank them x)
      Nev­er­the­less I’m glad it got rolling~

      • Darkhanum says:

        Guess I’ll do so too :P

        Any­way, that you are now in a retired sta­tus doesn’t erase the work you’ve done until now, so thanks for the third time xD

        Oh, just found your Remem­ber 11 review. I read Ever 17 some time ago and I just remem­bered I wanted to read that one too. Just felt like telling you.

        Well, con­grat­u­la­tions for hav­ing such a nice blog ^^

  14. hariseldon says:

    Any­body read this one? It has a sim­i­lar premise to Sword Art online.

    Moon­light Sculp­tor
    Syn­op­sis: The mas­ter of flat­tery who will pour praises upon NPCs if it will get him one more cop­per coin! The avatar of hard work who is will­ing to hit a dummy with­out rest for 1 month in order to gain stats! For Wid every­thing and any­thing he does in the viru­tal real­ity of Royal Road is related to his one goal.

    Make money, become num­ber one and use the fame and power to make even more money. Enough to say good­bye to poverty forever!

    What he doesn’t know how­ever is that fate has another thing in mind for him…

    - One of, if not the most pop­u­lar game novel series in Korea, Moon­light Sculp­tor fol­lows the devel­op­ment of the main Char­ac­ter (Wid) through his tri­als and tribu­la­tions. Through the story so far he has picked up new friends, admir­ers, and devoted ene­mies aplenty from his time as the ter­ror of the Con­ti­nent of Magic (A game he played before start­ing RR). A char­ac­ter who over­comes impos­si­ble odds through sheer hard work with­out rely­ing on any bugs or bal­ance break­ing items! Read this and you won’t be disappointed!

    the first vol­ume is already trans­lated to Eng­lish from Korean.

    • Aorii says:

      Oh cool, I’ll check it out; do love these kind of series. Thanks for the rec­om­mend~! ^o^

    • Akira says:

      Yeah I have to sec­ond this story. The plot is great and it’s really really inter­est­ing. The only thing that both­ers me is that the sec­ond vol­ume isn’t trans­lated and can’t find the raws for the story anywhere.

  15. Myanx says:

    I quote every word you used.
    I also think the first arc should have ended with­out the last chap­ter, which I found really dis­ap­point­ing in its anti­cli­max and incon­sis­tency.
    He could choose another main char­ac­ter and fol­low sim­i­lar sto­ries in oth­ers worlds for next vol­umes.
    Yet he decided to con­tinue telling a story of char­ac­ters that had already told all they had to tell.
    Lack of plot plan­ning and courage to BE a writer, and not just sell­ing books imho. Really a pity.

    • Aorii says:

      Mmmh, I have mixed feel­ings on that one. Keep going with a char­ac­ter after its devel­oped isn’t nec­es­sar­ily a bad thing. A char­ac­ter that’s set up allows more focus on story and, to my great plea­sure in SAO, set­ting (I love the MMO seed).
      Also to be fair, the light novel indus­try (and manga) doesn’t exactly encour­age long-term plan­ning from the begin­ning, not unless you’re famous already (which Reki wasn’t) and knows what you wrote is going to be pub­lished for long time to come.

  16. clark says:

    i really liked the story of this anime.. can any­one sug­gest other ani­mes that has the same story con­cept like this one? of course aside from hunter x hunter which i already saw the greed island chap­ter which was awe­some and just like sword art online.. please do tell me guys if you know other ani­mes that are like this..

  17. Porporkis says:

    Hon­estly, the Eng­lish ver­sion is pretty bad. The plot­line doesn’t con­nect, and the trans­la­tion isn’t great. It sounds like more of a mechan­i­cal struc­ture rather than a piece of work. I found myself hav­ing a hard time fol­low­ing the story and remain­ing inter­ested.
    Anime was much bet­ter. ;p

  18.  
Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge